Manga Series Review – Witch Watch & Sakamoto Days

Two series I’ve been semi-actively reading for a while now just finished up, so it seems as good a time as any for a brief review and a small amount of retrospection. I don’t think there’s much value in summary, so instead I’m just gonna jot down some thoughts.

Witch Watch

Witch Watch is a lot of things at once, but the easiest way to describe it is as a comedy series, with some rom-com elements, and some lighter shonen combat. It does a bunch of things very well, the biggest one for me being managing the transitions between it’s Shonen Fighting arcs, and it’s slice of life/gag of the week arcs incredibly effectively. All of the characters incredible weirdos, with even the “straight man” Morihito being capable of driving the comedy of chapter.

That said, if I had to note my favorite thing about the series, it’s probably that it very deliberately and immediately steers away from the “we have to keep our magic powers hidden” trope, which I find insanely boring for many reasons. The main character Nico reveals that she’s a Witch almost immediately to everyone, and everyone is… mostly cool with it!

It also means that magic and magic use can be used for mundane things, and quite a few of the slice of life sections are based around Nico attempting to help people with magic, and not entirely succeeding.

If there’s any weakness to the series, it’s probably that some elements of the series end up feeling a little rushed at the end. It’s not the worst thing, but it does mean the last 10 or so chapters feel a bit less developed then many of the other combat arcs. Still, I think Witch Watch is fantastic, and if you like comedy shonen, it’s a good read.

TLDR: I recommend it.

Sakamoto Days

I think Sakamoto Days is probably the more popular of the two, which is a shame, because I like it a lot less. Again, it’s another Comedy Shonen, but partway through, it mostly just turns into battle shonen, and as a battle shonen… hmm. The best way I can describe it is as functional, but displeasing.

There’s a bunch of incredibly stupid world building and backstory. I can’t remotely take the Japanese Association of Assassins seriously, and the one part of the later story that does present some interesting/horrifying hypotheticals gets dealt with in like 2 chapters.

Credit where it’s due though, I will say that chapter 208 is one of the more impactful things I’ve seen in a shonen series, and is likely to stick with me for a while.

Witch Watch was really good at switching between comedy and combat arcs, in ways that were both compelling. Sakamoto Days switches into a combat arc, and never really leaves. It becomes busy, and overbearing, and in many ways not interesting. Kinda reminds me of Naruto’s 4th Great Ninja War arc if I’m being honest.

It’s a shame, because it does combat comedy really well early on, but the character arcs and goals and everything else become really cluttered in ways that made me just kind of check out during the last 30-40% of the series.

While I wouldn’t recommend against reading the series, I would suggest that it’s worth keeping in mind that if you really enjoy the first volume or so, that’s not actually what you’re going to get for the remainder of the run.

More posts